Download the SaaS SEO Guide PDF

Over 60+ page SaaS SEO Guide in PDF format so you can read it whenever you want!

SaaS SEO Guide
SimpleTigerSimpleTiger
Web Design
·
6/6/2025
·
20
 min read

How To Choose a Web Design Agency That Drives Business Growth

Get unique insights in your inbox
How To Choose a Web Design Agency That Drives Business Growth
Web Design
Last updated: 
June 6, 2025
June 13, 2025
Table of Contents
Schedule a free demo

Your website is the digital face of your business, yet most companies blindly choose a web design agency based on price or portfolio alone. This mistake can cost thousands in lost revenue.

Learning how to choose a web design agency that focuses on business results rather than just aesthetics could be the difference between a website that generates leads while you sleep and one that simply looks pretty but fails to convert.

This post highlights the importance of selecting a web design agency that works as a partner with your business, guiding you through the design process to create a highly effective converting tool that drives growth. 

Why the Right Agency Impacts Your Revenue

A funnel showing the various steps of an agency’s process of website design, including business goal alignment, performance-driven design, and conversion-focused execution

Choosing the right web design agency directly impacts revenue growth, conversion rates, and market positioning. Your website functions as your most hardworking salesperson, operating 24/7 to engage potential clients and drive revenue.

Your web design partner should understand business metrics like monthly recurring revenue (MRR) and customer acquisition costs, not just create something that looks good. When evaluating potential agencies, look for those who speak about measurable outcomes rather than visual aesthetics.

Professionally designed websites can increase conversion rates by up to 200% compared to poorly designed ones. This translates directly to your bottom line, especially for SaaS companies where small improvements compound over time.

The True Cost of Poor Web Design

A poorly designed website costs you more than just the money spent building it. For every second your site takes to load, conversion rates drop by approximately 4.42%. This means slow, poorly optimized websites are silently bleeding potential revenue every day.

8 Steps To Select a Web Design Agency

Finding the right web design partner requires a systematic approach. Follow these seven critical steps to identify an agency that will drive meaningful business growth rather than just deliver an attractive website.

1. Define Goals and KPIs

A businessperson holding a magnifying glass and examining a document with KPIs. 

Start by clearly outlining what success looks like for your website before approaching any agency. Without specific goals, you'll have no way to measure if your investment delivers results.

Effective website KPIs to consider:

  • Conversion metrics: Free trial sign-ups, demo requests, and actual purchases
  • Engagement metrics: Average session duration and pages per session
  • Performance metrics: Load time, mobile responsiveness, and accessibility scores

Document these goals and share them with potential agencies during your discovery calls. The best agencies will ask about your growth targets before discussing design aesthetics.

2. Prioritize Messaging Over Aesthetics

When choosing a web design agency, it's essential to prioritize quality messaging that resonates on a personal level with your customers. According to Hostinger, 38% of users will stop engaging with a website if the content or layout is unattractive—proof that poor design and content are symbiotic.

However, messaging should always come first. Your website’s copy must directly speak to your audience’s needs, pain points, and desires in a clear and relatable way. This personal connection is the bedrock of creating engagement and trust, which are key to conversions.

Once the messaging is in place, the design aesthetic should work to support and enhance that copy. It should complement the message, not overpower it. A clean, user-friendly design can draw attention to key elements in your content, guiding users through your website seamlessly, with visuals that make the message easier to digest and act upon. Design should never be the hero of the site; the messaging that resonates with your audience is the true driver of engagement and conversions. 

Here’s how to make sure your messaging and design work together harmoniously:

  • Start with strong messaging that speaks directly to your audience’s needs and emotions.
  • Design should be supportive: It should complement, not compete with, your message.
  • Simplicity is key: Keep the design clean, focusing on user-friendliness and clarity.
  • Use design to enhance readability: Proper layout, typography, and spacing should make the message easier to digest.
  • Engagement is the goal: Design should help guide users to interact with the key content and calls to action.

When evaluating potential agencies, ask how they ensure that the design supports the message and how they plan to craft a website that prioritizes customer connection through impactful and simple messaging.

3. Assess Portfolio Quality

Look beyond visual appeal when reviewing an agency's portfolio. Dig into the results their work has generated. Many agencies showcase beautiful designs but remain silent about performance metrics.

When evaluating how to choose a web design company, ask these pointed questions:

  • How did the website impact the client's conversion rates?
  • What was the percentage increase in organic traffic after launch?
  • How did the design process incorporate SEO best practices?

The most valuable agencies will have data-backed case studies showing measurable improvements in traffic, engagement, and conversion metrics.

4. Check Relevant Experience

Industry-specific experience matters significantly when choosing a website designer. An agency that specializes in your sector will understand your audience's expectations, competitive landscape, and conversion patterns.

For SaaS companies specifically, look for agencies with experience in:

  • Designing effective product tours and demos
  • Creating conversion-optimized pricing pages
  • Building intuitive user onboarding flows

For example, an agency with SaaS experience will understand the nuances of subscription-based business models and how to design for the unique buyer journey in your industry.

5. Evaluate the Team's Process

A flowchart showing the various steps in a website design process.

The agency's design and development process reveals how they'll handle your project from start to finish. A structured approach indicates professionalism and reliability.

Key process elements to evaluate when you choose a website designer:

  • Discovery phase: How thoroughly do they research your business and users?
  • Communication plan: How often will you receive updates, and in what format?
  • Approval workflows: What is their process for feedback and revisions?

Ask about their communication protocols and how they handle timeline delays. The best agencies maintain transparency throughout the process and involve you at critical decision points.

🌐 Ready to Find Your Ideal Web Design Partner?

We've helped hundreds of SaaS businesses scale from seed funding through to acquisition with conversion-focused web design. Let us help you create a website that drives business growth!

SimpleTiger
SimpleTiger

6. Confirm SEO and Growth Marketing Focus

Your website must be built with search visibility and conversion optimization as foundational elements, not afterthoughts. Many beautiful websites fail to perform because they weren't built with marketing performance in mind.

When figuring out how to pick a web design company, look for those who:

  • Conduct keyword research before information architecture
  • Build with technical SEO best practices from the ground up
  • Design with conversion rate optimization principles

The agency should discuss how its design decisions support your marketing goals. If they talk exclusively about aesthetics without mentioning performance metrics, that's a red flag.

7. Consider Budget and ROI

A scale with two elements; one with dollar signs and money bags, another with a website showing growth.

Web design pricing varies dramatically across agencies, but focusing solely on the lowest bid often leads to disappointing results. Instead, evaluate the potential return on investment each agency can deliver.

What to consider beyond the price tag:

  • Ongoing value: Will the site continue to evolve and improve after launch?
  • Maintenance costs: What are the long-term costs of keeping the site updated?
  • Scalability: Can the website grow as your business expands?

The most cost-effective agency isn't necessarily the cheapest; it's the one that delivers the highest return on your investment through increased conversions and business growth. Keep this in mind as you allocate marketing budget to a new website.

8. Factor in Post-Launch Support

Your website is never truly "finished." It requires ongoing optimization based on user behavior and business changes. The best agencies offer robust post-launch support and continuous improvement services.

When determining how to choose a website design company, ask about these essential post-launch services:

  • A/B testing and conversion rate optimization
  • Performance monitoring and speed optimization
  • Content updates and additions

Ask potential agencies about their post-launch packages and how they measure ongoing success. The right partner will view your website as a living asset that requires continuous nurturing to maximize ROI.

Moving Forward With a Growth-Driven Web Partner

Selecting the right web design agency is a critical business decision that extends far beyond aesthetics. The agency you choose will directly impact your ability to attract, engage, and convert visitors into paying customers.

The most successful SaaS companies approach web design as a strategic business investment rather than a creative expense. They select partners who understand their unique business model, speak the language of metrics and conversions, and design with growth in mind.

At SimpleTiger, we've spent over 15 years helping SaaS companies create websites that drive predictable growth. We combine proprietary AI technology with proven conversion strategies to accelerate a typically slow process. Our approach focuses on the critical 20% of actions that yield 80% of your results, ensuring you see tangible improvements in conversion rates quickly.

If you're ready to transform your website into a growth engine that consistently delivers new customers and revenue, schedule a demo today! We'll show you exactly how our data-led strategy can help you outpace competitors and create a website that truly drives business growth.

FAQs

How do I evaluate a web design agency's portfolio effectively?
What questions should I ask a web design agency before hiring them?
What are the red flags to watch for when choosing a web design agency?
How much should I expect to pay for professional web design services?

Takeaways

  • Define clear business goals and KPIs before contacting agencies so you can measure the true impact of your website investment
  • Look for agencies that back up their portfolio with data, like conversion rate improvements and SEO performance, not just pretty designs
  • Choose a web design agency with industry-specific experience, especially if you're in SaaS, to ensure they understand your audience and growth model
  • Prioritize agencies that integrate SEO, CRO, and growth marketing into their design process from the start, not as an afterthought
  • Don’t just ask about launch—make sure your agency offers ongoing support, testing, and optimization to keep your site performing over time
SimpleTiger
SimpleTiger
Download our SEO for SaaS guide for free!
Download PDF
SimpleTigerSimpleTiger

Ready to get started?

Schedule a Discovery Call and see how we've helped hundreds of SaaS companies grow!

TestimonialsTestimonials
Schedule a Free Demo
Or learn more about our pricing.
SimpleTiger
SimpleTiger

Learn more about Web Design

Actionable insights to help you grow your SaaS and dominate your search market!

Get The Latest Content Straight In Your Inbox!

SimpleTiger
SimpleTiger

SaaS SEO Guide Call to Action

Over 60+ pages detailing how to grow your SaaS company using a proven SEO process.

SimpleTiger
SimpleTiger